Christians and Fellow Heretics

Saturday, April 23, 2011

Reading Balthasar on Holy Saturday

For this day of Holy Saturday, between Good Friday and Resurrection Sunday, I turned to a philosophical-theological meditative study by Juan M. Sara on the biblical motif, reflected in the Apostle's Creed, on the descent of the Lord Jesus Christ in his final step of abnegation into hell. Crucified, dead, and buried, Jesus Christ then descended into hell.

Of late, this blog has had much to do with the current controversy among Evangelicals on the book by pastor Rob Bell, Love Wins - a book about Heaven, Hell, and the fate of every person who ever lived (HarperOne publishers, released for sale March 2011).

This blog previously referred to how leading evangelical theologian, Richard Mouw, president of Fuller Theological Seminary, Pasadena, California, refused to anathematize Rob Bell, a Fuller graduate.  I referred also to the pioneer of biblical soteriological universalism, Rev. Neal Punt, a Christian Reformed pastor and theologian who was put on trial in the local council of his denomination, the CRC's Chicago Classis (as they call it), in 1985.  Pastor Punt underwent serious lengthy interrogation, he answered and as well he held the classis accountable for not removing dissent when it is a faithful possible interpretation of Scripture.  Punt did not remove the doctrine of God's wrath from our Reformed and reformational theology (as any such removal woud, among other things in faithful Christian doctrine, also have removed the Son's free entry into that wrath in crucifixion, death, and burial).  After Christ's crucifixion, death, burial, and (I woud say, in accord with the Apostle's Creed) descent into hell (descensus ad inferno) which brings at the extreme depth of descent the still point where the the call to God by that dead descent depth brings the dawn of hope and the reversal of movement, from hell back to God on earth, the resurrection.  The culminating descent, according to Roman Catholic philosophical-theologian, Hans Ur von Balthasar, is part of the Redemption of Humanity and your own salvation with our species.

Read more »

Labels: , , , ,

Monday, April 18, 2011

Neal Punt on Rob Bell's controversial book, Love Wins -- heaven, hell & fate of everyone who ever lived

Frequently Asked Questions No. 24
Three observations about Bell’s book, 
Love Wins**


by Neal Punt

 Two critical and one positive observation about Rev. Rob Bell’s book, Love Wins.
  

    THE FIRST ― It is impossible to overestimate the value that the Bible places on the name of God. Therefore we know that Exodus 34:6, 7 reveals a pivotal truth about God and his relationship to sinners:

          “And he passed in front of Moses, proclaiming [His Name], ‘The
            Lord, the Lord the compassionate and gracious God, slow to
            anger, abounding in love and faithfulness, maintaining love to
            thousands, and forgiving wickedness, rebellion and sin. Yet he
            does not leave the guilty unpunished’ ” (Ex. 34:6, 7).

      Unquestionably God speaks here about two distinct groups of sinners. The one group experiences the gracious abounding love of God in the forgiveness of their sin. The other remains in their guilt. The continuing existence of these two separate groups has to do with “proclaiming” something about God’s name.

       The Bible has many stories (accounts) about these two distinct groups. These biblical accounts can be chronicled. The two groups are never joined together and no one ever passes from one group to the other. Using the familiar metaphors we can say the one group experiences “heaven” the other “hell” on earth.

       Bell melds these two entities into a single mass of human beings that at times experiences Gods “abounding love” (“heaven”) and at other times is punished because they are “guilty” (“hell”). This “heaven” and “hell” are real, according to Bell, and have a major effect on our present day life.  Whether we experience this real “heaven” or “hell” depends on how we use the freedom of choice that God has given us.

Read more »

Labels: , , ,

Meditation: Evangelical novelist George MacDonald on death and new life

ThinkChristian:


"The seed dies into new life


and so does man."




-- George MacDonald, evangelical novelist
     and proponent of soteriological universalism


"I have never concealed the fact that I regarded him as my master; indeed I fancy I have never written a book in which I did not quote from him." C.S. Lewis

Read more »

Labels: ,